Perspectives · November 5, 2026

The two-sided problem of pricing a marketplace

Setting a fair price on a platform means thinking about two different people's sense of value at once, and that is harder than it sounds.

James Song · Founder, Prevail Holdings Inc.

Pricing a single product is already difficult. Pricing a marketplace is harder, because the price has to make sense to two different people who are looking at the same transaction from opposite sides and valuing it differently. The seller on Franopolis is paying for exposure to serious buyers. The buyer is paying, in time and sometimes in fees, for access to opportunities worth their attention. If the price only makes sense from one of those vantage points, something in the marketplace eventually breaks, even if the revenue line looks fine for a while.

I have watched marketplaces price themselves into trouble by focusing entirely on what the paying side will tolerate, without asking whether the arrangement still feels fair to the side that is not writing a check. A marketplace that charges sellers aggressively while giving buyers a mediocre experience eventually loses the buyers, and a marketplace without engaged buyers has nothing left to sell sellers, no matter how reasonable the fee structure looks on paper. The price has to be judged by its effect on both populations, not by the revenue it produces for one of them.

Why we resist pricing on anxiety

There is a version of marketplace pricing that works by creating urgency — limited slots, scarcity language, pressure to decide quickly before an opportunity disappears. It can increase conversion in the near term. It also teaches both sides of the marketplace that the platform is more interested in closing transactions than in producing good ones, and that lesson, once learned, is very hard to unlearn. We have avoided pricing or presenting listings in a way that manufactures anxiety, even when it would likely move more transactions through the platform faster. A buyer deciding whether to commit to a franchise should be making that decision with a clear head, not a rushed one, and a platform that profits from rushing them has picked the wrong kind of growth.

The harder discipline is resisting the pricing decisions that would show up favorably in a short reporting period but would quietly change what kind of platform we are. A price increase on sellers might raise revenue this quarter and reduce the pool of serious sellers over the following two years. A buyer fee might convert well in isolation and discourage exactly the thoughtful, careful buyers we most want using the platform. Each of these trade-offs has to be thought through on a longer timeline than the decision itself seems to require.

A price has to be judged by its effect on both sides of the marketplace, not by the revenue it produces for one of them.

Pricing as a signal, not just a number

What I have come to believe is that pricing on a marketplace is a signal as much as it is a revenue mechanism. It tells both sides what kind of platform they are dealing with — whether it respects their time, whether it is trying to extract the maximum from a single transaction or build toward a long relationship. We try to price in a way that signals the second, even when the first would be easier to justify in a single meeting. Over the years I have been doing this, that signal has turned out to matter more than almost any individual pricing decision we have made.

← All perspectives

Next perspective

What I owe the people who run our companies

Ownership is usually described in terms of what it is owed. I think about it more often in terms of what it owes back to the people doing the work.